This
is the talk I gave to the inaugural Southern Nevada Teacher Leadership Symposium in Las Vegas Nevada on November 21st 2014.
I was honored to be asked to speak to such a distinguished group of teacher leaders and look forward to helping to build teacher leadership in Nevada.
My
name is Jeff Hinton and I am the 2014 Michael Landsberry Nevada Teacher of the
Year, National Board Certified Teacher and teacher leader. Before I begin my
talk this evening I would like to thank the many organizations that made this
conference possible and for inviting me to share with you my thoughts on the
important topic of teacher leadership so thank you to the, Clark County School
District, Clark County Education Association, Nevada Department of Education, Southern
Nevada Regional Professional Development Program, University of Nevada at Las
Vegas, National Board of Professional Teaching Standards, Nevada Succeeds, Public
Education Foundation, Teach for America, Got Core Values, City of Las Vegas/Downtown
Achieves, Boys and Girls Club, and the United Way.
Thinking
about the various organizations involved in this conference, I think it is
obvious that this is not going to be an ordinary seminar. In fact in my many
years of attending such events I have never seen this many outstanding and
diverse organizations gathered together to further teacher leadership and
professionalization of the teaching field. They are here because they realize
that teacher leadership is the sleeping giant of education reform, it is the most
obvious way to advance student learning, while at the same time creating a way
for our district’s most highly accomplished teachers to share their wealth of
knowledge and expertise with others, while at the same time allowing them to grow
professionally without leaving the classroom where our best teachers are needed
most. Nothing is as powerful as an idea
whose time has come and teacher leadership is indeed a very powerful idea.
We Have Work to do in Nevada
As
you all know Nevada recently celebrated its sesquicentennial anniversary. In
the last 150 years our Battle Born state has experienced booms and busts,
triumphs and defeats, but no matter how desperate the times, we managed to come
back, and come back stronger than ever before. And we’re doing it again as we
throw off the last vestiges of a great recession that crippled our economy but
not our spirit.
Our
economic future is bright as new businesses open their doors and many others like
Tesla Motors gigafactory prepare to do so. Despite Nevada’s incredible economic
comeback we have a lot of work to do in other essential services, but in my
opinion none is as important or as dire as our public education system. In a
recent Las Vegas Sun article, Nevada ranked last in the nation in high school
graduation rates with only 63% of its students earning a degree. In the 2014
Kids count data book, an annual publication that assesses child well-being in
four domains: economic wellbeing, education, health, and family and
community. Across the 50 states and
District of Columbia, Nevada ranked 48th overall. The National Assessment of
Educational Progress or NAEP is the largest nationally representative and
continuing assessment of what America's students know and can do. The test is
given in grades 4 and 8 and covers reading and math It is considered the “gold standard” of
educational achievement. The report shows that 66% percent of Nevada’s fourth
graders and 72% of its eighth graders fell below proficiency in math. 73% of 4th
graders and 70% of eighth graders in Nevada fell below proficiency in reading. I
should point out that there has been slight gains over the last few years, but clearly
more needs to be done. The Brookings Institute recently published a report
indicating that Nevada is quickly growing jobs in the STEM fields of Science,
Technology, Engineering and Math but unfortunately Nevada is not producing enough
workers with the necessary skills to fill those jobs.
Nevada
clearly needs to do more to improve our education system. As we look back at
the past 150 years and celebrate where we have come from, it is now time to
plot a course for the future. We have a unique opportunity to reimagine what is
possible in education, to break down old barriers, and overcome the challenges of
antiquated thinking and archaic approaches. We can choose to be idle observers of change,
or we can decide right here and right now to be leaders of that change. To create a system of teacher
leadership that will be held up and admired across the nation. It will be hard
work, but it will be work worth doing. Teacher Leadership is that new way
forward.
What is Teacher Leadership?
Over
the last few weeks I have been asking my colleagues and friends to tell me what
they thought about teacher leadership. A few teachers remarked that they didn’t
know teachers could be leaders, some were excited by the notion of teacher
leadership, most, however had no idea what I was talking about. Sean McComb the
2014 National Teacher of the year told me that teacher leadership is about
recognizing the instructional expertise that teachers bring to the table and
structuring roles to capitalize on those strengths to improve instruction and
thereby achievement for all. The Teacher Leadership Exploratory Consortium defines
teacher leadership as “the process by which teachers influence their
colleagues, principals, and other members of the school community to improve
teaching and learning practices with the aim of increased student learning and
achievement.”
The
truth is teacher leadership can mean a lot of different things to a lot of
different people, and there isn’t one single definition or job description that
encapsulates all that teacher leaders can do. To further clarify what teacher
leadership means The National Education Association created seven domains for
teacher leadership they are:
Domain I: Fostering a
collaborative culture to support educator development and student learning
Domain II: Accessing and using research to improve practice and student learning
Domain III: Promoting professional learning for continuous improvement
Domain IV: Facilitating improvements in instruction and student learning
Domain V: Promoting the use of assessments and data for school and district improvement
Domain VI: Improving outreach and collaboration with families and community
Domain VII: Advocating for student learning and the profession
Domain II: Accessing and using research to improve practice and student learning
Domain III: Promoting professional learning for continuous improvement
Domain IV: Facilitating improvements in instruction and student learning
Domain V: Promoting the use of assessments and data for school and district improvement
Domain VI: Improving outreach and collaboration with families and community
Domain VII: Advocating for student learning and the profession
Looking at this list it soon becomes apparent that most teachers are “teacher leaders” in some way and to some degree already.
Barnet
Berry the founder and CEO of the Center for Teaching Quality or CTQ coined the
term “teacherpreneur” to describe this
emerging field. Teacherpreneurs are
teachers who lead, but don’t ‘leave’ their students or schools. They have taken
on leadership opportunities to further their career, yet are still able to
devote time to classroom teaching. They mentor new teachers, lead school
improvement efforts, develop curriculum and provide professional development
for their colleagues. In addition, teacher leaders may serve as policy
advisors, liaisons between schools and the communities they serve, and conduits
for building parent relationships. A recent Metlife Survey of the American
Teacher found that half of teachers already have leadership roles in their
school. Teachers serve as department chairs, instructional resources, teacher
mentors, or leadership team members. The report found that half of teachers are
at least somewhat interested in teaching in the classroom part-time combined
with other roles or responsibilities in their school or district, including 23%
who are extremely or very interested in this option.
Professionalization of the Teaching Field & Need for
Teacher Leadership
The
education reform debate is complex and multifaceted, there are many proposals
as to how to effectively improve student learning to include raising standards,
holding teachers accountable for their student’s learning by tying their
achievement on standardized tests to teacher compensation, lengthening the
school year, decreasing class size, higher per pupil funding and activating
market forces by giving students a choice as to where they can go to school by
providing vouchers and promoting charter schools, but most would agree that the
first and most important step to improve education is to make sure that there
is a high quality teacher in every classroom. Unfortunately teacher morale is
at an all-time low. A recent survey indicates that teacher satisfaction has
declined 23 percentage points since 2008, from 62% to 39%, including five percentage points since last
year alone. Teacher satisfaction is the lowest its been in 25 years. Half of teachers report feeling
under great stress several days a week, an increase of 15 percentage points, over
36% of teachers reporting that level in 1985.
In addition, nationwide, enrollments in university teacher-preparation
programs have fallen by about 10 percent from 2004 to 2012, according to
federal estimates from the U.S. Department of Education's postsecondary data
collection.
With
fewer students interested in entering what has recently been called the
“embattled profession,” the question
becomes, how do you attract & retain the best and brightest students into
the field? The Clark County School
District started the year with over 600 teacher vacancies, requiring the need
for substitute teachers in critical areas such as math. Many of the vacancies
occurring in at risk schools, which disproportionately affect kids who can
least afford it. The New York Times recently wrote that “At the moment, the
average teacher’s pay is on par with that of a toll taker or bartender.
Teachers make 14% less than professionals in other occupations that require
similar levels of education.” Those individuals who possess the qualities the
teaching profession is looking for have been lured away from teaching to
careers that can offer real incentives for motivated individuals. There are few
career paths for classroom teachers who desire to take a leadership role and
become part of the process.
Traditionally,
if a teacher wants to take on more responsibility, earn more money and gain
prestige they would go into administration. But for many teachers leaving the
classroom is not an option. Their passion is teaching students and most
teachers do not want to give up what they love most. In addition, it is these
highly effective teachers that should stay in the classroom where their
talents, knowledge and experience can be best put to use and shared with their
colleagues and students alike. According to the New Teacher Project (TNTP) 20 %
percent of teachers “who are so successful that they are nearly impossible to
replace” leave their schools as a result of “neglect and inattention.” Research indicates that in order to increase
the likelihood that Gen “Y” teachers remain in the profession they need
opportunities to participate in decision making at the school and district
level; a positive and supportive school culture which fosters teamwork and
effective lines of communication; professional opportunities that include
collaboration and technology; in-depth feedback and support from administrators
and colleagues; time set aside for regular collaboration, with a fair and a
differentiated compensation structure which includes rewarding outstanding
performance, acquiring new knowledge and skills, and assuming new roles and
responsibilities.”
We
need to create within the system career paths or trajectories that do not take
the teacher out of the classroom fulltime but develop hybrid roles in which
teacher splits their day between teaching and teacher leadership
responsibilities. This is not a novel idea, some of the best performing school
systems in the world already have advancement opportunities for their best and
brightest teachers. The International Summit on the Teaching Profession
recently released a report titled “Building a High-Quality Teaching Profession:
Lessons from Around the World.” In the world’s leading school systems teachers
have a variety of paths for career advancement that involve “horizontal
movement” that is a greater range of responsibility that does not take the
teacher out of the classroom.
The
National Network of State Teachers of the Year published a report titled
“Re-Imagining Teaching: Five Structures to Transform the Profession.” In it
they cited the need for a career trajectory to attract and retain top teaching
talent. According to the report
“Research on continuums in other fields tell us that it takes ten years to
develop expertise in a profession, and that such expertise is developed through
deliberate practice. A loss of over 40% of teachers annually, inhibits the
ability to develop a solid cadre of expert practitioners. Given the time it
takes to develop expertise, the annual loss of teachers is exacerbated by the
long period of time it takes to replace the experienced teachers that leave.
This lack of a cadre of expert
practitioners not only impacts the profession but impacts efforts to distribute
leadership as there are fewer expert practitioners to take on leadership
positions within a school.” This is especially so in at-risk schools, where
teacher turnover is highest and our students most in need of highly
accomplished teaching talent.
In
addition, “while many professions are moving to flatter organizations with
greater value placed on middle-level experts and fewer top-level positions,
leadership in teaching is still organized as a top-down structure.” There has been modest movement across the
nation to formalize teacher leadership. A survey of the country finds that two
states and one jurisdiction currently have comprehensive teacher career
initiatives, Twenty states currently have multi-tiered certification systems
with tiers for advanced or master teachers, eight states currently have
certification endorsements related to teacher leadership, three states have
“designations” for master teachers, four states have adopted continuums of
teaching practice rubrics, and only one state has adopted policies for and nine
states are exploring the development of teacher licensing systems linked to teacher effectiveness. As I have stated earlier, we have a
unique opportunity to capitalize on the cooperation and shared enthusiasm of so
many disparate organizations to see teacher leadership develop in our
state.
Advocating for our profession
Teacher
leaders need to advocate for their profession. We can no longer sit on the
sidelines and wait for reforms to be done to us, but rather we must take an
active role in shaping policy and changing perceptions of what teacher leaders
are and can be. We must initiate the
conversations at our work sites, talk with other teachers and administrators
about teacher leadership. Teacher leadership must develop at the grassroots
level, it cannot be another top down mandate, and we must be the voice. I
recently had a conversation with a colleague about teacher leadership and Peer
Assistance and Review (PAR) in particular.
She told me that she didn’t trust it, that she believed that PAR was a
way for the school’s administration to use their pet teachers to spy on underperforming
teachers. She perceived it as another top-down mandate and obviously didn’t
have much buy in or faith in the idea. After talking with her about teacher
leadership, what it is, and who teachers leaders are. She began to understand the
way in which highly accomplished teachers can be a useful resource for new and
remedial teachers.
But
advocating for our profession can go beyond face to face conversations. Social
media can be a powerful way to deliver our message and connect with others who
share similar ideas. Today social networks have cache, as more and more
individuals and institutions use social media it has become increasingly more
important to have a digital presence. Doing so will help you connect and be
connected to important voices in teacher leadership and it is an excellent way
to stay informed and keep abreast of the latest research and initiatives in
this emerging field.
Teacher
leaders need to be engaged in policy and understand the issues so that they can
clearly explain them to parents and stake holders. As the state teacher of the
year, for example, people want to know my position on a variety of issues like the
Common Core. You will have people ask you your thoughts about the Nevada
Performance Framework, merit pay, charter
schools, vouchers, alternative routes to licensure, tenure reform, first in last out, and the list goes on. It is important that as
a teacher leader that you be able to speak with authority to these issues. As a
teacher leader your colleagues and the public will come to you with their
questions and concerns regarding education policy, and when they don’t come to
you, must go to them as a an advocate for what we are trying to do.
Challenges:
As
promising as teacher leadership is, it is not necessarily right for all
teachers. Some may not want to, or be able to take a leadership role in their
schools. There will be many challenges to implementing teacher leadership. I
recently asked my State Teacher of the Year colleagues what they thought the
greatest challenges to teacher leadership are. Kathy Collins Assini 2014 New
Jersey Teacher of the year pointed out that:
“Not
every teacher wants to be a leader, but teachers should look to support those
who do and who have the capacity to be leaders. However, every teacher that
wishes to be a teacher leader does not necessarily have the skills and demeanor
to be one. Working with adults is not the same as teaching students. Where does
the training come from? Does it come once someone is identified or do you train
and see who passes the test? Does the Administration always see the same
characteristics in a teacher leader as the staff does? Often times very
different skills are needed. So often we have heard that it is tough to be a
profit in your own land. I think often times the most resistance comes from
within our own ranks. "What do you mean she will only have to teach 4
periods when I have to teach 6?" There has to be a clear definition of
what the teacher leader will do and what they will be responsible for. Also
there has to be a clear delineation between teacher leader and administrator if
the leader’s job is to coach and assist fellow teachers. In many districts
there is not a lot of trust, so it is hard for teachers to let someone in, both
figuratively and in reality.”
I
would like to take the opportunity to point out that Administrators are
absolutely essential to making teacher leadership work and it is important that
we include them in designing teacher leadership models. According to the
Teacher Leadership Exploratory Consortium “Teachers in leadership roles work in
collaboration with principals and other school administrators by facilitating
improvements in instruction and promoting practices among their peers that can
lead to improved student learning outcomes. By doing so, they support school
leaders in encouraging innovation and creating cultures of success in school.
Teacher leadership can neither be effective nor successful without principal
support, but neither can the principal maximize his or her effectiveness
without harnessing the talents and expertise of teachers in leadership roles.” A recent Metlife report indicated that 75% of
principals feel the job has become too complex.
Job satisfaction among principals has decreased nine percentage points
in less than five years, to 59% very satisfied down from 68% very satisfied in
2008. A distributive model of school leadership could potentially take pressure
off of the principal as teachers and administrators work together to improve
student achievement allowing principals to focus their time and energy on the
day-to-day operation of the school, and highly accomplished teachers focused on
student achievement through various teacher leader initiatives.
My path to Teacher Leadership
I want to talk a little bit about my path to teacher
leadership. Before I was a teacher, I
was a U.S. Marine. There were certain principles that the corps instilled in me
that I carry with me to this day. The Marines taught me to accomplish the
mission no matter what, to be dedicated to the task at hand, but most
importantly the Marines taught me the importance of teamwork. Marines also lead
from the front, that is to say that I would never expect another Marine to do
something that I wasn’t prepared or able to do first.
I
knew that I wanted to be a teacher leader before I knew there was such a thing,
using the lessons I learned in the Marines I honed my skills in my content area
and pedagogy by earning master’s degrees in both curriculum & instruction
and U.S. History from UNLV. I also sought out every new opportunity I could
find to expand my repertoire in regard to teaching and learning. Through the
last thirteen years I have been involved in numerous professional development
opportunities to include being a James
Madison Graduate Fellow, Barringer research fellow at Thomas Jefferson’s
Monticello, veteran of several Gilder Lehrman summer seminars for teachers, and
the Rock n Roll Foundation’s summer seminar at New York university among others.
These wonderful experiences have helped me grow as an educator exposing me to
new experiences and giving me the opportunity to collaborate with teachers
across the country. Over the years I have done my best as a department leader
and colleague to foster collaboration and teamwork within my own workplace,
unfortunately there has been a persistent and stubborn legacy of teachers
working in isolation. Classrooms become fiefdoms of which teachers seldom
stray, and visitors seldom enter.
But
the most impactful professional
achievement of my career by far has been earning National Board Certification.
When I meet another National Board Certified teacher I know they are a teacher
who takes their profession seriously, they are committed practitioners who are
dedicated to student achievement, they are teachers who go above and beyond
what is required to hone their craft. National Board Certified Teachers are
reflective practitioners committed to becoming better teachers to drive student
achievement. Of course there are teacher leaders who are not National Board
Certified, but it is the mark of professional distinction and in district of
almost 18,900 teachers, only a little more than 2% are National Board
Certified. It is an exclusive club, but one in which I hope becomes less so in
the near future.
Earlier
this year state teachers of the year met together in Arizona to discuss
educational issues and to prepare for the upcoming year as teacher leaders. One
activity that stuck with me was a role playing scenario in which teachers
assumed the role of a teacher, concerned parent, administrator, community
member and public official. We had the opportunity to look at key educational
policy issues through the lens of various interest groups, and I became very
interested in the political side of education. So much in fact that I became a
candidate for the Nevada State Assembly this past election cycle. Early this
month voters in my district informed me, however, that my services would not be
needed in Carson City this coming legislative session. While I lost the
election, I did learn about how our political system works, and more
importantly I stepped out of my comfort zone by putting myself in a new and
sometimes uncomfortable situation. I see teacher leadership the same way. Teacher
leaders will have challenges, and we will be required to step outside of our
regular routines and will undoubtedly find ourselves in difficult and maybe
even frightening situations, but this is how we grow. This is how we become
teacher leaders.
In Summary
In
conclusion, we have a lot of work to do to realize our vision of teacher
leadership. Leveraging institutional change will not be easy, as it is natural
to cling to the status quo even when that means persistent failure. The time is
right for a paradigm shift and I believe we have the support to do it. The
Teacher Leadership Exploratory points out that a prerequisite for successful and effective
teacher leadership, is changing the cultures of schools so that teachers are
accepted as leaders among their peers and that old norms of teaching, working
in isolation are replaced with new norms of collaboration and teamwork. Of
course this is going to require a restructuring of the teacher work day so that
teachers have the time built into the day for collaboration. This requires a clear articulation of school
wide goals, training of principals as well as teachers to understand the role
of teacher leaders and support for teachers and other education professionals to
work together to serve the needs of all students in the school.”
Teacher
leadership is in its infancy in Nevada.
We will need to work hard to deliver our message to policy makers and
stakeholders so that they will see that empowering our highly accomplished
teachers to take on leadership roles within their school communities is in the
best interest of students and their learning. This must be a grass roots effort.
We have seen the backlash over the years at perceived top-down mandates, and as
a result, we need to have this effort led by teacher practitioners if we are to
have the support of our colleagues. One of the biggest obstacles to this effort
will be our perennial nemesis, time! We need time to collaborate, time to
reflect, time to assess student data, and time for meaningful professional
development.
Historically the field of education has been
slow to adapt to change, and when change comes, it is seen by many to be the
“reform of the day” soon to be forgotten as the next “new thing” is foisted
upon teachers weary from the last reform that didn’t work. Teacher leadership
however is not a new concept, it is not a new reform, we have been doing it for
years, but we just called good teaching and professionalism. The difference is
now that teachers need to be recognized, supported and compensated for their
leadership. We must have a way to share our experience, knowledge and passion
with our colleagues for the benefit of student achievement. I hope that you
will join me and the other passionate, dedicated professional educators
gathered here tonight to commit to furthering teacher leadership in the state
of Nevada, the stakes have never been higher, the opportunity has never been
greater and the future has never been brighter.